Vol. 13 No. 1 (2022): The Bibliographic Control in the Digital Ecosystem

Should catalogue wade in open water?

Paul Weston
Università di Pavia

Published 2022-01-13


  • Digital resources description,
  • Metadata management,
  • Digital preservation strategy,
  • Professional education,
  • Catalogue mission,
  • Digital resources retrievability
  • ...More

How to Cite

Weston, Paul. 2022. “Should Catalogue Wade in Open Water?”. JLIS.It 13 (1):215-33. https://doi.org/10.4403/jlis.it-12743.


In recent years, libraries, either on their own or in consortia, have carried out digitisation projects which resulted in establishing criteria to make digital items accessible through the catalogue. Pushing the boundaries of the latter, cataloguers have considered the possibility of providing access to the digital version of a work whenever available in the public domain. Librarians have now started to question whether the catalogue, moving past the idea of being just a citational tool, should open itself to the web as the place where users, thanks to quality data, can gain easy access to freely available digital bibliographic material. This should include digital publishing, as well as DH projects, all of which are based on editions published in printed format.

This scenario urges to find quick policy answers: a. how should features which could act as search keys or filters be adequately described; b. how should flexibility and changeability of digital objects be dealt with; c. how traditional cataloguing procedures should change as a consequence of the number and the peculiarities of these items; d. which criteria should be adopted in marking the new border lines of the library / catalogue mission.


Metrics Loading ...


  1. British Library. 2019. Foundations for the Future: The British Library’s Collection Metadata Strategy 2019-2023. London: British Library. https://www.bl.uk/bibliographic/pdfs/british-library-collec- tion-metadata-strategy-2019-2023.pdf
  2. Chiappe Laverde, Andrés, Yasbley Segovia Cifuentes, and Helda Yadira Rincón Rodríguez. 2007. “Toward an instructional design model based on learning objects.” Education Technology Research and Development:671–681. doi:10.1007/s11423-007-9059-0.
  3. Dempsey, Lorcan. 2019. “What Collaboration Means to Me: Library collaboration is hard; effec- tive collaboration is harder.” Collaborative Librarianship 10 (4, art. 3):227-233. https://digitalcom- mons.du.edu/collaborativelibrarianship/vol10/iss4/3
  4. Guerrini, Mauro. 2020. Dalla catalogazione alla metadatazione. Tracce di un percorso. Prefazione di Barbara B. Tillett. Postfazione di Giovanni Bergamin. Roma: Associazione italiana biblioteche.
  5. Lemon, Barbara, Kerry Blinco, and Brendan Somes. 2020. “Building NED: Open Access to Aus- tralia’s Digital Documentary Heritage” Publications 8 (2):19. doi:10.3390/publications8020019.
  6. Library of Congress. Network development and MARC standards office. 2020. MARC 21 Format for Bibliographic Data. Update No. 31. 856 – Electronic location and access. Washington, DC: Li- brary of Congress. < https://www.loc.gov/marc/bibliographic/bd856.html>.
  7. Mandillo, Anna Maria. 2002. “La nuova legge sul deposito legale: una riforma non solo per le biblio- teche”, AIB notizie 14 (3):4-7. .
  8. Puglisi, Paola. 2020. “Deposito legale quattordici anni dopo: come, quando, ‘quanto’, e perché” AIB Studi 60 (3):591-614. doi:10.2426/aibstudi-12477.
  9. Sardo, Lucia. 2017. La catalogazione: storia, tendenze, problemi aperti. Milano: Editrice bibliografica.
  10. Schrimpf, Sabine, and Yvonne Tunnat. 2019. “306.2 15 Years of nestor: German Network of Ex-
  11. pertise in Digital Preservation (paper Presentation).” OSF. June 20. doi:10.17605/OSF.IO/HA5VN.
  12. Smith-Yoshimura, Karen. 2020. Transitioning to the Next Generation of Metadata. Dublin, OH: OCLC Research. doi:10.25333/rqgd-b343.
  13. Tennant, Roy. 2017. “’MARC Must Die’ 15 Years On” Hanging together, the OCLC Research blog, October 15, 2017. < https://hangingtogether.org/?p=6221>.
  14. Trombone, Antonella. 2018. Principi di catalogazione e rappresentazione delle entità bibliografiche. Presentazione di Diego Maltese. Roma: Associazione italiana biblioteche.
  15. Werf, Titia van der. 2021. “Next Generation Metadata... it’s getting real!” Hanging together, the OCLC Research blog, March 4, 2021. https://hangingtogether.org/?p=8918&utm_campaign=ab- stracts-6-it&utm_medium=email&utm_source=pardot&utm_content=metadata-opening-plena- ry-hanging-together-blog-post&utm_term=emea-it-abstracts.